What to Wear to ‘Practical Magic 2’

All products and services featured are independently chosen by editors. However, StyleCaster may receive a commission on orders placed through its retail links, and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.

Practical Magic 2 hits theaters on September 10, bringing the return of Sandra Bullock as Sally Owens and Nicole Kidman as Gillian Owens. Whether you’re planning to go opening week or once fall officially starts later this month, you might be wondering what to wear to watch the sequel. Luckily, the Owens sisters aren’t your typical witches, and their wardrobes are a mix of bohemian and late 90s style that is easily to layer into your fall wardrobe, so you’ll get plenty of wear out of these Practical Magic 2 outfits. 

What to Wear to Watch Practical Magic 2, at a Glance

• Best Dress: Attitudes by Renee Jersey Illusion Waist Maxi Dress, $53 (was $66)
• Best Lace Jacket: Lioness Long Nights Lace Maxi Dress, $110
• Best 90s Dress: Cider Mesh Flocking Floral Sweetheart Ruffle Sleeve Mermaid Midi Dress, $40
• Best Slip Dress: Siteluoyg Spaghetti Strap Midi Satin Silk Dress
  , $45
• Best Sweater: Target dELiA*s Scarf Pullover Sweater, $35
• Best Tank Top: Old Navy Asymmetrical Lace-Trim Cami Top, $24 (was $30)
• Best Long Sleeve Top: Urban Outfitters Kimchi Blue Irene Sheer Lace Ruffle Bell Sleeve Top, $45
• Best Maxi Skirt: Free People Emberwood Flannel Maxi Skirt, $168
• Best 90s Skirt: Verdusa Fishtail Mesh Long Skirt
  , $30
• Best Boots: Amazon Essentials Women’s Fitted Stretch Ankle Heel Boots
  , $35

Whether you’re going for a comfy and casual look with an oversized sweater, midi slip skirt, and boots, or want to slip on something dressier for a girls’ movie night, there are so many ways to lean into the fall witchy vibes of Practical Magic. Ahead, we share our favorite moody fall style finds for all of your Practical Magic outfit needs, including a perfect lace layer from Nordstrom, a witchy bell-sleeve top from Urban Outfitters, and a 90s-inspired slip skirt
from Amazon that Sally Owens would totally have worn in the original movie. 

Dresses

Attitudes by Renee Jersey Illusion Waist Maxi Dress

On Sale 20% off

A simple black dress such as the Attitudes by Renee Jersey Illusion Waist Maxi Dress can go a long way in your Practical Magic 2 outfit planning. Wear this dress on its own with ankle boots and a wool overcoat on chilly nights, or layer a lace number like the Lioness Long Nights Lace Maxi Dress on top for something that feels a bit more mystical. 

QVC Deal: New customers can get $20 off their first $40+ order with promo code HELLO20. 

Sizes Available: 2XS-2X
Colorways: 3  

QVC is  a StyleCaster sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.

Lioness Long Nights Lace Maxi Dress

Style the Lioness Long Nights Lace Maxi Dress over a slip dress
or tank top and mini skirt, then throw on boots for the ultimate 90s witchy look. This sheer lace number is something you’d totally find in the Owens sisters’ wardrobe, making it a fab Practical Magic look. We also love that it’s not too obvious and is versatile enough to wear throughout fall. 

Sizes Available: XS-M
Colorways: 2

Belle & Bloom Heavenly Bodies Lace Slip Dress

A black lace slip dress screams 90s witch in a Practical Magic kind of way, and the Belle & Bloom Heavenly Bodies Lace Slip Dress is the chicest way to wear the style to see the sequel. Wear this with a chunky cardigan and heeled boots for a girls’ movie night. 

Sizes Available: S-L
Colorways: 1

Cider Mesh Flocking Floral Sweetheart Ruffle Sleeve Mermaid Midi Dress

When dressing for Practical Magic 2, lean into the late 90s silhouettes as much as possible to get that quintessential Owens sisters look. If black lace is too witchy for you, this Cider Mesh Flocking Floral Sweetheart Ruffle Sleeve Mermaid Midi Dress is something we think Sally Owens would wear. It’s available in three colorways, including a gorgeous burgundy that is on trend this fall. 

Sizes Available: 2XS-XL
Colorways: 3

Siteluoyg Spaghetti Strap Midi Satin Silk Dress

When styling ourselves for a movie night, we prefer to invest in pieces that we can get more than one wear out of, and this slip dress
from Amazon is a fall wardrobe staple. For Practical Magic 2, we’d grab the dress in the solid black color and layer it with the Lioness Long Nights Lace Maxi Dress and some boots. But the dress is available in a whopping 40 colors, including some 90s-inspired floral prints that Sally Owens would totally wear. 

Sizes Available: XS-XL
Colorways: 40

Tops

CherryBetty Vintage Floral Puff Sleeve Top

If your Practical Magic aesthetic leans more Aunt Franny than Sally and Gillian Owens, this Amazon top is a must for movie night. The CherryBetty Vintage Floral Puff Sleeve Top
has a classic witchy silhouette that would look cute with a ruffled skirt and some boots for a quirky ensemble.  

Sizes Available: M-2XL
Colorways: 2

Old Navy Long-Sleeve Asymmetrical Unlined Mesh Top

On Sale 32% off

The Old Navy Long-Sleeve Asymmetrical Unlined Mesh Top is another 90s-coded top that styles well for a Practical Magic 2 showing, but is versatile enough to wear all throughout the fall, whether you’re pairing it with a midi skirt and boots or a pair of corduroy pants and sneakers. 

Sizes Available: XS-4XL 
Fits Available: Regular, tall, petite
Colorways: 3

Bottoms

Shoes

Amazon Essentials Women’s Fitted Stretch Ankle Heel Boots

A classic pair of heeled ankle booties will go far in your fall wardrobe and works especially well for Practical Magic 2 outfits. For a budget-friendly pick that will arrive fast, go with the Amazon Essentials Women’s Fitted Stretch Ankle Heel Boots
. These boots come in four colorways—including black leather and black microsuede, which is perfect for the movie—and have a 2.75-inch heel, so they add height without being too tall for a casual movie night with friends. 

Sizes Available: 5-13
Fits Available: Regular, wide 
Colorways: 4

Jeffrey Campbell Sweet Talker Snip Toe Boots

If you want to splurge on a pair of boots that you can wear all season long, the Jeffrey Campbell Sweet Talker Snip Toe Boots are it. These boots come in 12 colorways, and all would work well for a Practical Magic 2 showing (though the black distressed and black embossed are our favorite options). Wear them with maxi skirts, midi dresses, wide-leg jeans, and more this fall. 

Sizes Available: 6-11
Colorways: 12

Accessories

Alex + Ani Celestial Cat Inline Necklace

Lean into the witchy vibes with the Alex + Ani Celestial Cat Inline Necklace. This necklace is not only a cute finishing touch for almost any Practical Magic 2 outfit, but you can also get a lot of wear out of it during spooky season, too. 

Chain Length: 17 inches (with a 2-inch extender)
Finish: Two-tone

Stackable Creations Leather Choker Necklace

For classic witchy style, a leather choker necklace is a must. This Stackable Creations Leather Choker Necklace
comes in seven colorways, including a solid black that looks good with all kinds of Practical Magic 2 outfits, whether you’re putting something together as a nod to the aunts’ whimsical style or channeling your inner Gillian Owens. 

Chain Length: 12 to 18 inches 
Metal Type: Stainless steel
Colorways: 7

Psychedelic Pinup Quartz Tiger’s Eye Necklace

In the original Practical Magic movie, Gillian Owens wears a tiger’s eye necklace for protection. This Psychedelic Pinup Quartz Tiger’s Eye Necklace from Etsy is inspired by the jewelry piece, with a similar layered quartz and tiger’s eye design. 

Chain Length: 18 inches 
Gemstone: Quartz and Tiger’s Eye 
Finish: 18K gold-plated

Why you should trust StyleCaster

The StyleCaster shopping team is dedicated to finding the best products, brands, services, sales, and deals across fashion, beauty, lifestyle, and entertainment. We make sure to stay on top of the latest trends, too. From knowing a brand’s offerings like the back of our hands to updating prices to hunting down discount codes and hacks to identifying alternatives, we do a thorough job at suggesting products that deserve your attention and money.

This story’s author, StyleCaster contributing writer Jessie Quinn, scours the internet for the best of the best to ensure readers walk away with items recommended by our team, industry experts, and more. For this story, she watched the original Practical Magic for outfit inspiration, and also researched red carpet looks from the sequel’s premiere.